What is a Clawback Provision in Law?

A clawback is a contractual provision under which a reward, bonus or compensation is returned, cancelled, forfeited or recovered. Sometimes, the person returning the reward pays a penalty in the event of fraud, misconduct or breach of contract. The law states that the award can be forfeited whether or not it has been paid, vested or distributed. This happens for specific reasons. Clawback provisions mostly apply in the financial sphere but may also apply in government contracts and the medical field. 

What’s an Example of a Clawback Provision?

An example of a clawback provision is Medicaid, where a company can reclaim payments made for healthcare purposes to Medicaid beneficiaries after they pass away. Below are other examples of clawback provisions.

  • Returning dividends under certain circumstances, such as bankruptcy.
  • When contractors and suppliers fail to meet certain conditions as per the agreement.
  • Businesses can claw back pensions in the case of fraud or when the pensioner suppresses information.
  • When an employee violates the terms of the agreement, such as working for a rivalry company.
  • Premiums paid to an insurance company can be clawed back or refunded after the policy cancellation within a certain timeframe.

It is worth noting that in most cases, provisions refer to incentives or rewards like bonuses or other compensations. They protect a business from losses in case of misconduct, fraud or other unexpected employee performances. 

What is the Clawback Rule?

The clawback rule is the list of standards a company must adopt, disclose, and abide by the compensation clawback policy. This rule was proposed in 2015 under section 954 of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act, also known as the Dodd-Frank Act. The rule was issued to recover the erroneously awarded compensation or clawback. A company or business can recover or claw back the money or benefits. The compensation could occur under certain circumstances or event and also involves executive compensation. The clawback rule also protects companies against unexpected circumstances that affect their integrity. 

What is a Clawback Provision in Private Equity?

Clawback provision in private equity refers to the rights of limited partners to reclaim extra compensation given to general partners. This occurs after the realization that the compensation resulted in losses, meaning the general partners received higher compensation. A clawback can happen under specific circumstances, such as selling company shares during bankruptcy or within the lock period after giving out dividends.

Private equity rescues the company when it is struggling to grow. This is why clawbacks come in handy. The clawbacks can help entities invest and earn profits. This can make the company highly competitive and increase its worth. A clawback provision in private equity also helps rebuild investors’ trust and loyalty, thus, giving the company a platform to invest more. It provides valuable protection for the company and community.  

Are Clawback Provisions Enforceable?

Clawback provisions are enforceable. But this depends on the provisions of the specific written agreements between the parties. As per the clawback clause, employers or companies can clawback benefits awarded to their employees in the case of a breach of contract or misconduct.

Clawback enforcement is the right of a company or business to recover compensation following the events that triggered the cancellation of the bonus or compensation awarded. This helps reduce future executive rewards in the event of financial restatements. Companies can avoid future financial risks by applying clawback provision enforcement.

It can also deter future fraud, which is why companies may need enforcement. However, it is important that the clawback provisions are explicitly stated and put in writing and should also be signed. Without agreeing or on provisions, the employee may not be able to claim that the employer attempts to claw back or recoup previously issued compensation.

Have questions?

Find a complex business litigation attorney near you.